Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

Topic: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting (Read 13267 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

August 11, 2013, 08:46:27 am

A black evening if there ever was one, it was clear from the first few minutes that we were dead meat and our season with it.
Well, we still need to rate our performance, so please, do vote this week. I expect a pretty ugly set of figures, but that is nothing less than we deserve at the moment.

[1] Votes add up to 15.
[2] No more than 10 votes to any individual.
[3] At least players need to be mentioned.
[4] Please include a rating.

Re: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

Reply #1 – August 11, 2013, 12:07:40 pm

Looks like no votes for anybody today.

Re: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

Reply #2 – August 11, 2013, 12:23:10 pm

5 votes

ciccone cosmetics

Re: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

Reply #3 – August 11, 2013, 01:30:44 pm

Quote from: thrunthrublu – on August 11, 2013, 12:23:10 pm

5 votes

ciccone cosmetics

lol, will pass this onto Frank

Re: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs Voting

Reply #4 – August 11, 2013, 03:09:10 pm

Oh well, if nobody else is willing to put in their 2 cents worth, then I may as well. Even though the anger is still deep within me.

Team:   E
But for the 3rd quarter, I'd be tempted to give us an 'F'. We were actually playing some decent football until Judd was injured. That was the last yelp we gave.

Votes:
[4]   Judd
[3]   Mclean
[2]   Curnow
[2]   Betts
[1]   Jamison
[1]   Scotland
[1]   Warnock

Explanations:
[4]   Judd:   This wasn't a classic Judd performance, but things are entirely relative. Clearly our best player, Juddy went back into a role where he was the workhorse, and he did it very well. When he went off injured, we lost our way and whatever drive from the centre we'd managed to claw back.
It is a sad state of affairs when our best player only plays 3 quarters.
[3]   McLean:   Brock worked as hard as anyone on the day and gave us something in a badly beaten midfield.
[2]   Curnow:   Worked hard and did OK.
[2]   Betts:   Best game from Eddie in weeks! Since early in the year, in fact. Eddie took some nice marks and was always dangerous.
[1]   Jamison:   Took out the Dogs' tall forward, but lost confidence in himself badly.
[1]   Scotland:   Plenty of the ball. OK.
[1]   Warnock:   In the end he probably came out on top of Minson, but he struggled early. He did manage to keep Minson to 1 mark. Not our worst by a long way!

Honourable Mentions:
Cachia:   Worked hard, but isn't having as much effect as he did earlier in the season.
Bootsma:   Like Jamo, he appeared to lose confidence in himself. He came back and did some really good defensive work, but he gave no drive at all. His huge torpedo just shows what he can do if he had confidence to attack sometimes.
Gibbs:   I so want Bryce to be back in the midfield, giving us some drive.
Murphy: not our worst, but only a shadow of himself at the moment.
Watson:   Until he got injured, he wasn't that bad.