CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Topic: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond (Read 9100 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

August 17, 2013, 08:24:54 pm

This week this should be a more pleasurable task. It was fun being there!

Remember:
[1] Votes must add up to 15.
[2] No one player can have more than 10.
[3] At least 3 players need to get a mention.
[4] Give our performance a rating.
It won't be 'E' or 'F' this week!

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #1 – August 17, 2013, 09:13:20 pm

b
4.Robinson
3.McLean
2.Gibbs
2.Simpson
1.Curnow
1.Tuohy
1.Casboult
1.Jamison

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #2 – August 17, 2013, 09:45:54 pm

A much more pleasurable time this week, and a lot of guys who contributed well, although only 3 4 quarter players.
Team:   A
Just!
Our best game for a quite a while, we really showed a fair bit of spirit.

Votes:
[3]   Robinson
[2]   Mclean
[2]   Curnow
[1.5]   Tuohy
[1.5]   Warnock
[1]   Gibbs
[1]   Simpson
[1]   Walker
[1]   Jamison
[0.5]   Casboult
[0.5]   Murphy

Explanations:
[3]   Robinson:   One of his best ever efforts, his heroics in the 2nd term turned the match around. He really showed what he can do with his attack on the ball.
[2]   Mclean:   Broke had a good game. Richmond didn't respect him and he made them pay. Pity his legs can't make him run down the guys he chased in the last quarter.
[2]   Curnow:   Obliterated an excellent player in Cotchin and still managed useful possessions at a better percentage.
[1.5]   Tuohy:   Took Dustin martin to the cleaners! Only had 11 possessions himself, but his goal was excellent and his man did nothing.
[1.5]   Warnock:   Good effort in the ruck against a top opponent. Also managed to hold Maric to 1 chest mark while on him.
[1]   Gibbs:   Best game for some time, with some excellent goals and much better attack on the ball. Still can do better, but he was 100 times better than last week.
[1]   Simpson:   They tried to knock him down, but he kept getting up and getting the ball. Great game.
[1]   Walker:   Best game for ages, Walker showed a lot more smarts than he has shown for ages.
[1]   Jamison:   Top job in defence. Killed 3 different opponents, especially Riewoldt after he killed Boots early.
[0.5]   Casboult:   A great return for a big man. Loved his marking, while his ruck work was better than it has been.
[0.5]   Murphy:   Not yet 100 %, but a real step in the right direction. he was brilliant early in the game.

Honourable Mentions:
Scotland:   A much better effort from Heath this week.
Henderson:   Started like a bomb, but couldn't get near the ball for 2 quarters.
Menzel:   Showed a lot of promise and made the most of every possession.
McInnes:   A great game from Andrew coming back from injury. He showed a lot of poise.
Armfield: Did a great job shutting Ellis out of the game after quarter time while being dangerous himself.
Graham:   Pretty good effort from a guy who came on late in the 3rd quarter. Looks promising.

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #3 – August 17, 2013, 11:26:17 pm

Team A-

3: Robinson
3: Simpson
2: Curnow
1: Casboult
1: Jamison
1: Gibbs
1: Mclean
1: Touhy
1: Warnock
1: Scotland

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #4 – August 17, 2013, 11:37:55 pm

Team B+

3 - Scotland. Leadership. Showed his team mates how to 'compose' under pressure.

3 - McLean. Hard & capitalised.

3 - Simpson. Leadership.

2 - Robbo. Disciplined. Got a glimpse of what MM will get from this kid.

1 - Armfield, shut down a potential game winner.

1 - Casboult, as his confidence grew, he stamped himself on the game and may have been the difference.

1 - Curnow. Needs no explanation.

1- Zackery. Tore Martin a new one.

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #5 – August 18, 2013, 01:59:14 am

Team A

5 McLean
3 Robinson
3 Casboult
2 Simpson
1 Gibbs
1 Walker

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #6 – August 18, 2013, 09:58:58 am

Team A

2: McLean
2: Curnow
2: Tuohy
1: Robinson
1: Henderson
1: Casboult
1: Scotland
1: Menzel
1: Gibbs
1: Armfield
1: Jamison
1: Simpson

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #7 – August 18, 2013, 10:19:22 am

5 Robinson
4 McLean
2 Jamison
2 Walker
2 Simpson

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #8 – August 18, 2013, 10:23:43 am

Team B

5 Brock
4 Curnow
3 Simpson
2 Tuohy
1 Robbo

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #9 – August 18, 2013, 02:57:21 pm

Team B (first 1/4 was cr#p, they scored too easily)

5: McLean
4: Robinson
3: Curnow
2: Walker
1: Simpson

HM: Touhy,Armfield,Murphy,Casboult,Scotland,Gibbs,Jamieson,Henderson

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #10 – August 18, 2013, 03:53:23 pm

First quarter: D
Last 3 quarters: A/A+
Overall: B+

3 McLean
2 Robinson
2 Curnow
2 Simpson
2 Tuohy
1 Armfield
1 Scotland
1 Gibbs
1 Casboult

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #11 – August 18, 2013, 05:51:03 pm

Team B
McLean 3
Robinson 3
Tuohy 2
Jamison 2
Curnow 2
Simpson 2
Gibbs 1

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #12 – August 18, 2013, 07:00:52 pm

Team; B+

5 - Gibbs
4 - McLean
3 - Robbo
2 - Curnow
1 - Walker

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #13 – August 18, 2013, 07:11:02 pm

Team = A (but only because I discounted the first 1/4)

2: Robinson
2: Simpson
2: Curnow
2: Mclean
2: Scotland
1: Casboult
1: Jamison
1: Warnock
1: Gibbs
1: Walker

Re: CSC Voting: Carlton vs Richmond

Reply #14 – August 18, 2013, 09:11:45 pm

Team B

4 - Simpson
3 - Robinson
2 - Touhy
2 - McLean
1 - Simpson
1 - Jamison
1 - Walker
1 - Armfield