ALFW B&F Thread February 05, 2017, 10:16:08 am Ladies and gentlemen, the moderating team has posed an interesting question that only you, the potential voters, can answer. What was posed was the existence of an ALFW B&F award.So, we need to answer a lot of questions and suggestions to the moderating team will be gratefully accepted.[1] Do you want one?[2] What should it be called?[3] What should the winner get?You get the idea.It was determined that we should have a 3 - 2 - 1 award at this point, until we can determine what may be the best long term solution (assuming the people want to vote at all). So, I'll start things off. However, please consider the necessities of this award. Even if there is an overwhelming voter response, we still have a lot of work to do before we can get something like the Jim Park.Round 1: Carlton vs Collingwood:[3] Brianna Davey[2] Darcy Vescio[1] Danielle HardimanWith apologies to Bianca Jakobsson, Nat Exon, Laura Attard and Lauren Arnell, all of whom deserve a vote. Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #2 – February 05, 2017, 11:57:13 am Quote from: crashlander – on February 05, 2017, 10:16:08 am[2] What should it be called?Name it after the woman who has done more for Carlton than any other!The Rita Silvagni Medal (is that a bit sexist )The idea would be to name it after a prominent woman player...my suggestion would be to leave it nameless for this season and name it after our first B&F winner. Quote Selected Last Edit: February 05, 2017, 12:09:11 pm by Lods
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #3 – February 05, 2017, 06:48:35 pm I'd prefer the same format as Jim Park ... but I don't tally the votes.3 - Davey2 - Jacobsson1 - VescioTeam: B+ As for the name of the award, how about someone from our last women's team? Quote Selected Last Edit: February 06, 2017, 08:09:12 am by DJC
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #4 – February 05, 2017, 07:26:17 pm Quote from: Lods – on February 05, 2017, 11:57:13 amName it after the woman who has done more for Carlton than any other!The Rita Silvagni Medal (is that a bit sexist )The idea would be to name it after a prominent woman player...my suggestion would be to leave it nameless for this season and name it after our first B&F winner.Was going to suggest the same thing....and tentatively call it the Vescio medal as she just picked up 3 votes. 3 - Vescio2 - Jacobson1 - Davey Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #5 – February 05, 2017, 07:35:31 pm Quote from: DJC – on February 05, 2017, 06:48:35 pmI'd prefer the same format as Jim Park ... but I don't tally the votes.It may be that we go down that path next year but with a short season we thought it best get something going, keep it simple, judge the interest (see how many vote each round) and build on it as the competition develops. Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #6 – February 06, 2017, 12:02:34 am A suggestion for the name, and even though she's a Bulldogs woman, she's the major reason that the women's comp even exists today, the Sue Alberti medal (at least for the first year until we have some Carlton women to name it after?? A lot mightn't know that Sue has been a major financial backer and vocal supporter of women's football for decades. She might have been the VP of the Western Bulldogs, but she's right behind all of the teams in the women's comp. She was at our game on Friday. As for my votes:3. Bri Davey2. Darcy Vescio1. Lauren Arnell Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #7 – February 06, 2017, 06:18:37 am Should be named the Vivian Kerr medal. Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #9 – February 06, 2017, 07:45:21 am 3. Bri Davey2. Darcy Vescio1. Lauren Arnell Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #10 – February 06, 2017, 07:45:39 am 3 Davey2 Arnell1 Vescio Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #11 – February 06, 2017, 07:52:24 am 3. Davey2. Vescio1. JacobsonVivian Kerr medal sounds good to me too. Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #12 – February 06, 2017, 10:29:31 am Quote from: Navy Maven – on February 06, 2017, 12:02:34 amA suggestion for the name, and even though she's a Bulldogs woman, she's the major reason that the women's comp even exists today, the Sue Alberti medal (at least for the first year until we have some Carlton women to name it after?? A lot mightn't know that Sue has been a major financial backer and vocal supporter of women's football for decades. She might have been the VP of the Western Bulldogs, but she's right behind all of the teams in the women's comp. She was at our game on Friday. As for my votes:3. Bri Davey2. Darcy Vescio1. Lauren ArnellI cant vote as I only saw a half.Sue Alberti can have their version of the Brownlow, rather than the CFC B+F.Shes a doggies woman anyway.It could be argued that the Jeannie Pratt medal would be good.Without the Pratts there might not have been a Carlton Football Club for a womans team to represent.I dont necessarily like that alternative either. Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #13 – February 06, 2017, 11:09:54 am My votes....3. Brianna Davey2. Bianca Jakobsson1. Darcy Vescio Quote Selected
Re: ALFW B&F Thread Reply #14 – February 06, 2017, 11:27:46 am Quote from: DJC – on February 05, 2017, 06:48:35 pmI'd prefer the same format as Jim Park ... but I don't tally the votes.3 - Davey2 - Jacobsson1 - VescioTeam: B+ As for the name of the award, how about someone from our last women's team? I like the Jim Park format myself, as I do spread my votes around somewhat. But with the questions around of the long term interest, I was a little dubious about tasking people to make such a commitment. 15 votes is a commitment and we don't have that many people who vote for the Jim Park every week.Assuming the interest continues, we may well head to that format.As for tallying up the votes, I assumed I was doing it. Quote Selected
Topic: ALFW B&F Thread (Read 30442 times)
previous topic - next topic
Topic: ALFW B&F Thread (Read 30442 times)
previous topic - next topic