Carlton Supporters Club

Tell me where it's wrong though. I know it reads like an absurdity, but take a look at the reality. It's like Gibbs has applied his voodoo over there. He's been there not 5 minutes and the Crows are a basket case after being the Grand Final the year before. Tell me that's a coincidence.  

Might just be Gibbs
Eddie B and big Sam didn't have the same spells.

Tell me where it's wrong though. I know it reads like an absurdity, but take a look at the reality. It's like Gibbs has applied his voodoo over there. He's been there not 5 minutes and the Crows are a basket case after being the Grand Final the year before. Tell me that's a coincidence.  

This is beyond absurd. What about the camp ? What about injuries to :
Luke Brown
Harry Dear
Rory Laird   
Tom Lynch
Rory Sloane
Riley Knight
Mitch McGovern
Paul Hunter   
Brodie Smith   
Brad Crouch
Taylor Walker

Those blokes are either out for large chunks of the season, or in and out over several weeks.

We've gone backwards since Gibbs left, so I guess applying your logic in reverse, he must have been our best player.

You forgot to add Jake Lever and Charlie C
Crows are a shadow of their side from last year.

He's prone to some "Massive" rants

Three number one picks, a number two pick, and Judd, not to mention Fevola, Stevens, Waite, Betts and another couple of hacks.
I won't get into yet another Pagan v Ratten barney, I'll only say that they were both bad appointments appointed for the wrong reasons, as was Malthouse.
We've lurched from one disaster to the next, and they've all been of our own making.

We had cream at the top but crap in the bottom half. The 2011 SF had 8.players off the rookie list. Other than Judd we had all those players were there under Pagan. Say what you want about Ratten he turned us from a basket case to finalist in 2 years.

We had cream at the top but crap in the bottom half. The 2011 SF had 8.players off the rookie list. Other than Judd we had all those players were there under Pagan. Say what you want about Ratten he turned us from a basket case to finalist in 2 years.

The truth is we should have stuck with Malthouse.

He had to change his ways MBB, and he couldn't.

The time of one man calling all the shots is dead, no one individual can possible hope to coach against panels of 6 or 8 experienced people! The group will always come out on top!

He would outcoach Bolton and his hapless bunch of cronies anyday.

It's very unlikely.

MM would have his moments like any good football coach, but on the whole he would be lost and confused unable to keep pace with the tactics or the game!

The systems we've put in place are the correct thing to do, now we just need to get it working which probably means pulling some square pegs from some round holes!

I think the next to go has to be the long term residents, we cannot keep chopping the newbies.

We had cream at the top but crap in the bottom half. The 2011 SF had 8.players off the rookie list. Other than Judd we had all those players were there under Pagan. Say what you want about Ratten he turned us from a basket case to finalist in 2 years.