Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda (Read 8713 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

This week is the clash of the bottom 2 teams.
I don't think we are as bad as the results have showed, but we certainly are not the contenders we hoped to be. While St Kilda played well last round for 3 quarters, they couldn't keep up the pressure. Hopefully, we can return to some sort of form against them.
Our squad should be about as good as it can be, but that doesn't appear to mean as much as it once did.

I will be going. I'll be in the Legends Stand, as close to the wing as I can manage.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #1 –
Battle of the cellar dwellers, but i'd like to think there is daylight between us.
Saints, at one stage at least, had 5 ex-carlton players, 3 or 4 of which was in their leadership group.
They have been our 2nds side of sorts.
I haven't seen anything from them this year other than their best player is sitting out similar to Liam Jones IIRC.

If we lose this one, heads will start rolling.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #2 –
Quote from: kruddler – on
Battle of the cellar dwellers, but i'd like to think there is daylight between us.
Saints, at one stage at least, had 5 ex-carlton players, 3 or 4 of which was in their leadership group.
They have been our 2nds side of sorts.
I haven't seen anything from them this year other than their best player is sitting out similar to Liam Jones IIRC.

If we lose this one, heads will start rolling.
Harford will be the first to be gonski.
2021-Pi$$ or get off the pot
2022- Real Deal or more of the same? 0.6%
2023- "Raise the Standard" - M. Voss Another year wasted Bar Set
2024-Back to the drawing boardNo excuses, its time
2025-Carlton can win the 2025 AFL Premiership
 

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #4 –
Team is in, and some BIG calls made.

OUT: Brooke Walker, Lauren Brazzalle, Charlotte Wilson - All omitted!
IN: Keeley Sherar, Maddy Guerin, Courtney Jones

Half wants committment and effort, and the 3 outs who have been staples for a while (when fit) have been lacking in that area, despite having more talent than some in the team.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #5 –
"Give me effort and i'll shutup"
Seems to have worked for Half with the changes playing well.
Well.....everyone playing well!

Dominating the loose ball, the hard ball and everything inbetween.

Highest score for the season....and its only half time.

Its funny how good the team looks when we play someone on a par, or below us.

if we had an easier draw to this point, we'd probably be in line for finals. As it turns out, we were fighting for last spot today.
Our effort so far shows that we are a much better side than that.

Individually...
Mimi Hill is dominating yet again. She looks a class above, the sidestep, the fend off, the tap/handball to advantage, the accuracy by foot and the speed/willingness to tuck and run. Complete package.

Georgia Gee is playing like we all know she can. Things happen when she has the ball. 'Female eddie' is number and relative skill level. Most skilled player in the team.

Plenty of others worthy of a mention, but lets save that for the post game.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #6 –
Full time.
48 - 2

Saints = lowest ever AFLW score, tied with Richmond. Worst thing for them is, they scored for the first 2 points of the game.

Then we took over....and the longer the game went, the better we looked.
Dominated.

Now in 9th, a couple games outside the top 6, but easier games to come from here.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #7 –
It was so much more enjoyable at the football this weekend! Alas, it was also a harbinger of things to come: I'm finding much harder working out who is who these days, and my glasses are not making enough of a difference. I won't be able to watch the football live for much longer.

But this wasn't about me. This was the girls coming home to play. You could see just how much it meant to the girls, before, during and afterwards.

[1] Moody is a long way from her best. To be honest, I don't think she'll get a lot better this year. Being sick and the restrictions on training mean that it will be next year before Moody is back to her athletic best.
That said, Moody had a good game. She kicked two good goals and took a couple of strong marks near to goal. Her ground work was good.
However, she did not dominate the ruck like she usually does, and had only one huge pound forward. The St Kilda ruck, Rhi Watt, had the better of her at the tapouts. That is never likely to occur again.
On the other hand, it did give Jess Good more time in the ruck and she did well. She competed well and also provided a marking target forward. She has a long way to go, but there is quite a bit to work with. her kicking is not a strength, but she did manage an excellent goal.

[2] We still miss a real key forward to kick the ball to. We moved the ball well today and ran a lot harder and, generally, more effectively, but there was never a straight line to goal. That said, we really did crate some opportunities. Darcy Vescio had her best game for the year.

[3] Mimi Hill is a real winner. She's been playing in the midfield and has provided something we've lacked there this year: real pace. Mimi was excellent again, and her kicking isn't that bad.

[4] We did have a real pace advantage over St Kilda today. Not just Hill, but Georgie Gee and Keely Sherar really stood out. Sherar's kicking is pretty dodgy, but she has a lot going for her otherwise. To see her just burn her opponents off and create forward chances was lovely. Maddy Guerin, Daisy Walker and Courtney Jones also showed excellent run.

[5] A worrying sign is that the Saints got the ball out of the middle better than we did. However, they rarely got the ball past Mua or Kezz. Our taller defenders really stood up today. Mua was brilliant, totally thrashing Greiser. Tilly Lucas-Rodd is playing a hell of a lot better for St Kilda than she ever played for us.
Maddy P was good, but not as outstanding as she can be. She looks to be carrying and injury. However, she still reads the play just so well and still got 20 possessions.

[6] Elise O'Dea and Jess dal Pos are really struggling. O'Dea has a big body and goes a lot of grunt work, but she is struggling to get the ball. Dal Pos appears to be past it. She really struggled to make an impact again and was probably our least effective player on the day. We cannot afford to play both of them, to be honest. O'Dea is useful because of her leadership, her versatility and her strength on the inside. You can justify a spot on that. I can't justify Dal Pos when we have other options fit and available. This is probably Dal Pos's best game statistically, and she did have a good tackle count, but her kicks missed targets and she was usually behind her opponent. if this is as good as she gets, then she is not a long term prospect.

[7] Nat Plane has not had a great year, but she did have a really solid game today. The same could be said for Gab Pound. Both did good things when it really counted and hit targets more often, something that we've been struggling with from defence.

[8] It was also good today to see the way we out-tackled the Saints. We got goals because of the pace and tenacity of our players. But a special mention to Abbie McKay, who may be only getting 14 - 16 possessions, but who really put her body on the line when it counted. When someone had to step up, she really put her foot forward.

[9] Lucy McEvoy and Grace Egan also look a long way from their best, but we are better with them playing.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #8 –
Did I mention Maddy Guerin? She probably doesn't do enough, all things said, but she really has depth to her kicking and her ability to break with pace stands out when she gets it. There is a lot to like here, but she does tend to go missing. Let's see how good she is when she plays four consistent quarters.
Live Long and Prosper!

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #9 –
That was much better, as it should be with possibly our strongest and best-balanced lineup on the park.  What a difference Jess Good makes!  Apart from being a forward target herself, Good’s ruckwork means that Moody gets a chop out and can go forward.  Tall forwards who can clunk a mark make the defenders very nervous.

I’d like to see the rules the umpires are asked to adjudicate; surely there’s not a Maddy Prespakis rule that prevents the umpires paying her free kicks  ::)
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #10 –
@crashlander
Bit hard on Gab Pound there crash.
She's been given votes the last 2 weeks. Missed the 2 games before that with Covid and was in the votes before that. Her only bad game was her first game, and that was just back after an injury.

O'Dea has been struggling. Her effort is consistent though. If anything, she gives away too many frees for being too eager.
Dal Pos is a huge disappointment. Offered us nothing apart from leadership and performance on field does not warrant a spot on the list, let alone in the team.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #11 –
I fail to see how this can be considered a healthy league when a 'professional' team scores two points for the day.
DrE is no more... you ok with that harmonica man?

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #12 –
Quote from: Professer E – on
I fail to see how this can be considered a healthy league when a 'professional' team scores two points for the day.

It was the (equal) lowest score ever, so its not like its common.

Some background though...
- Saints are a crap team who were always expected to be a bottom team anyway.
- Their best player chose to sit out the season ala Liam Jones.
- They only had 22 players to choose from, and 1 was a late omission, so the only fit players on the list played.
- They have to play again on wednesday. So once we got a few goals in front, they went into preservation mode.
- As you are probably aware, they are not really 'professional'.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #13 –
Quote from: crashlander – on
It was so much more enjoyable at the football this weekend! Alas, it was also a harbinger of things to come: I'm finding much harder working out who is who these days, and my glasses are not making enough of a difference. I won't be able to watch the football live for much longer.

But this wasn't about me. This was the girls coming home to play. You could see just how much it meant to the girls, before, during and afterwards.

[1] Moody is a long way from her best. To be honest, I don't think she'll get a lot better this year. Being sick and the restrictions on training mean that it will be next year before Moody is back to her athletic best.
That said, Moody had a good game. She kicked two good goals and took a couple of strong marks near to goal. Her ground work was good.
However, she did not dominate the ruck like she usually does, and had only one huge pound forward. The St Kilda ruck, Rhi Watt, had the better of her at the tapouts. That is never likely to occur again.
On the other hand, it did give Jess Good more time in the ruck and she did well. She competed well and also provided a marking target forward. She has a long way to go, but there is quite a bit to work with. her kicking is not a strength, but she did manage an excellent goal.

[2] We still miss a real key forward to kick the ball to. We moved the ball well today and ran a lot harder and, generally, more effectively, but there was never a straight line to goal. That said, we really did crate some opportunities. Darcy Vescio had her best game for the year.

[3] Mimi Hill is a real winner. She's been playing in the midfield and has provided something we've lacked there this year: real pace. Mimi was excellent again, and her kicking isn't that bad.

[4] We did have a real pace advantage over St Kilda today. Not just Hill, but Georgie Gee and Keely Sherar really stood out. Sherar's kicking is pretty dodgy, but she has a lot going for her otherwise. To see her just burn her opponents off and create forward chances was lovely. Maddy Guerin, Daisy Walker and Courtney Jones also showed excellent run.

[5] A worrying sign is that the Saints got the ball out of the middle better than we did. However, they rarely got the ball past Mua or Kezz. Our taller defenders really stood up today. Mua was brilliant, totally thrashing Greiser. Tilly Lucas-Rodd is playing a hell of a lot better for St Kilda than she ever played for us.
Maddy P was good, but not as outstanding as she can be. She looks to be carrying and injury. However, she still reads the play just so well and still got 20 possessions.

[6] Elise O'Dea and Jess dal Pos are really struggling. O'Dea has a big body and goes a lot of grunt work, but she is struggling to get the ball. Dal Pos appears to be past it. She really struggled to make an impact again and was probably our least effective player on the day. We cannot afford to play both of them, to be honest. O'Dea is useful because of her leadership, her versatility and her strength on the inside. You can justify a spot on that. I can't justify Dal Pos when we have other options fit and available. This is probably Dal Pos's best game statistically, and she did have a good tackle count, but her kicks missed targets and she was usually behind her opponent. if this is as good as she gets, then she is not a long term prospect.

[7] Nat Plane has not had a great year, but she did have a really solid game today. The same could be said for Gab Pound. Both did good things when it really counted and hit targets more often, something that we've been struggling with from defence.

[8] It was also good today to see the way we out-tackled the Saints. We got goals because of the pace and tenacity of our players. But a special mention to Abbie McKay, who may be only getting 14 - 16 possessions, but who really put her body on the line when it counted. When someone had to step up, she really put her foot forward.

[9] Lucy McEvoy and Grace Egan also look a long way from their best, but we are better with them playing.

Thanks Crash for the post, as always very informative and good reading.

As for the eye sight, you could try in buying a pair of binoculars. I have used them for years, not because of bad eyesight it just gives me a close up view of the action which sometimes you cannot be pick up from far away. Gives me a much different perspective of the game and how a play may of unfolded.

Only issue is that moving from the binoculars to normal eyesight your field of view is a lot narrower and it can take a second or two for my eyesight to adjust which can lead to missing some action at times.

Re: AFLW 2022 Rd 7: Carlton vs St, Kilda

Reply #14 –
I may have to try something like that. Thank you for the tip.

I really miss the eagle eyes I once had. I ALWAYS knew who had the ball and who kicked the goal, even when I was 9. It frustrates the hell out of me to be ... old. I guess I'm I'm only 60 (61 next Sunday), so what should I be worrying about?
Live Long and Prosper!