Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Topic: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide (Read 2887 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

July 14, 2023, 07:35:26 pm

Voting is as usual: you have 15 votes to award pretty much as you will, with the following provisos:
[1] 15 votes in total, no more, no less.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player (even Sam Walsh or Patrick Cripps)
[3] Three players at least must get a mention.
[4] A grade for the game, A+ (what I want to see) to F-.

I must admit, I haven't voted for the Freo game yet; I've only seen the first half. I should fix that problem tonight.

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #1 – July 15, 2023, 09:01:48 pm

Team A
5 SOS
3 TDK
2 Doc
2 Crippa
2 Gov
1 Mots
Honerable Mentions
Blacres, Walshy, Weiters

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #2 – July 15, 2023, 09:09:42 pm

Tough to vote this game

but this is definitely an A

5 Nic Newman - nine tackles and repelled everything and kicked a goal - what a game by Newy
4. Cripps - seven tackles nince clearances - led from the front today and was a monster.... so much so they had to bench Butters as Crippa was too much for them in the clearances which he had 10!!
3. SOS - great game by SOS - has to be in the votes this week.
2. Charlie - great game b Charlie without the flash and glamour -- what a fantastic team game he played.
1. TDK - 6 tackles 7 clearances and few important contested marks - an elite player developing in front of our eyes.

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #3 – July 15, 2023, 11:18:24 pm

Team A+

4 Silvagni
3 Acres
2 Motlop
2 Newman
2 DeKoning
1 Cripps
1 Charlie

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #4 – July 16, 2023, 12:22:48 am

Team A

3 Newman
2 SOS
2 Walsh
2 Doc
2 Cripps
1 McGovern
1 Curnow
1 TDK
1 Motlop

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #5 – July 16, 2023, 09:50:58 am

Team: A+ (first A+ I've given. We won every quarter against a premiership contender in great form, you can ask no more).

4 - Newman
4 - Silvagni
2 - Docherty
2 - Walsh
1 - Cripps
1 - Curnow
1 - McGovern

HM: Acres, Motlop & TDK. (there were no non-hackers/non-contributors).

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #6 – July 16, 2023, 10:19:53 am

AFL Rd 18:   Carlton vs Port Adelaide
11th vs 2nd and 11th kicks butt! One of the great wins of recent years. Port may not have treated us as seriously as we treated them, but more fool them!
Team:   A+

Votes:
The problem with performances like this is that to allow everyone who deserves a mention to get one, the votes get a bit watered down. Such is life. I much prefer it when we have a large number of good contributors.
[2.5]   Patrick Cripps:
[2]   Nic Newman:
[2]   Jack Silvagni:
[1.5]   Blake Acres:
[1.5]   Tom de Koning:
[1]   Sam Docherty:
[1]   Jesse Motlop:
[1]   Mitch McGovern:
[1]   Charlie Curnow:
[0.5]   Jacob Weitering:
[0.5]   Adam Cerra:
[0.5]   Matthew Cottrell:

Explanations:
[2.5]   Patrick Cripps:      If only Cripps could kick! 1 goal 3 and it should have been 4 goals! 10 clearances and 7 tackles.
[2]   Nic Newman:      Continued a stellar season with a brilliant game in defence. 9 score involvements from a BP! 9 tackles, a goal and 23 possessions was a dominant game.
[2]   Jack Silvagni:      Deserves about 5 votes. 4 goals and a strong showing as 2nd ruck, he took Port by surprise and took his chances.
[1.5]   Blake Acres:      Possibly his best game for us. His marking was excellent. Pity about his kicking.
[1.5]   Tom de Koning:   An excellent effort in the ruck and around the ground.
[1]   Sam Docherty:   Another 4 quarter effort from Doc.
[1]   Jesse Motlop:      Probably his best game to date, he made the most of his opportunities and kicked some rippers.
[1]   Mitch McGovern:   A great game in defence, providing huge run and great aerial work.
[1]   Charlie Curnow:   Charlie started dominantly. When H went off, Port managed to keep Charlie quiet for a while, but in the 3rd quarter Charlie broke out. 15 disposals, 11 marks and 12 score involvements. Pity his kicking wasn’t on.
[0.5]   Jacob Weitering:   Dominant early.
[0.5]   Adam Cerra:      Quieter than he has been, he still managed to make some excellent contributions.
[0.5]   Matthew Cottrell:   Another solid effort.

Honourable Mentions:
Adam Saad:      Just keeps producing. Dominated his position.
Alex Cincotta:      Another really solid effort in defence.
Jack Martin:      Not enough possessions, but what he did was excellent.
David Cuningham:   Providing class and drive, his disposal was excellent.
George Hewett:   Not back to his best, but solid.
Paddy Dow:      15 possessions and some really strong efforts.

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #7 – July 16, 2023, 10:52:56 am

Team: A+
5. Silvagni
4. Cripps
3. Newman
2. Acres
1. Motlop

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #8 – July 16, 2023, 11:02:08 am

Team A

5 Newman
4 Cripps
3 Silvagni
2 De Koning
1 Acres

Hard to imagine Charlie, Motlop and Doc not getting a vote, but it is what it is.

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #9 – July 17, 2023, 07:06:49 pm

Team: A+

5 - Silvagni
4 - Cripps
3 - De Koning
2 - Newman
1 - Motlop

Charlie was stiff to miss out but I had to give Jesse a vote for his remarkable quarter.

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #10 – July 17, 2023, 07:34:25 pm

Team A - that's 2 in a row!

3 Newman
2 Silvagni
1 De Koning
1 Cripps
1 Docherty
1 Motlop
1 McGovern
1 Curnow
1 Cerra
1 Cottrell
1 Martin
1 Cunningham

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #11 – July 17, 2023, 08:49:53 pm

Team A+

5: Newman
4: JSOS
2: Motlop
2: Cripps
1: Walsh
1: Acres

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #12 – July 17, 2023, 11:44:01 pm

Team A+

3 SOS
2 Newman
2 Walsh
2 Cripps
1 Acres
1 Doc
1 McG
1 TDK
1 Motlop
1 Charlie

HM Cuningham, Weiters, Saad .... I could continue. Top team first performance for 4q 👏🏼

Re: Jim Park Voting 2023 AFL Rd 18 Carlton vs Port Adelaide

Reply #13 – July 20, 2023, 04:52:34 pm

Team A+

3: Newman
3:Cripps
3: Silvagni
2: Docherty
1: Acres
1: C.Curnow
1: Walsh
1: DeKoning

HM’s: Great team effort but Mots especially deserves a mention.