Carlton Supporters Club

AFLW is not AFL.
Records shouldn't cross over.

One competition has been running for over 120 years.
A fledgling competition in it's infancy will always throw up skewed results like this.
It's only just settled on its final make-up.
In effect, it's only just beginning.

It's a fine achievement, but is in no-way comparable to the efforts of a team like Geelong.
I understand the need to promote the women's game but let it be against it's own standard.
It'll actually be easier in respect of most records not to be compared.

I'm not going to argue this one.
Folks will have their own opinion as to the legitimacy of the claim.
From my point of view I find it a bit bizarre comparing records over two completely different competitions.

Quote from: Lods – on November 01, 2025, 09:09:11 pm

I'm not going to argue this one.
Folks will have their own opinion as to the legitimacy of the claim.
From my point of view I find it a bit bizarre comparing records over two completely different competitions.

Who has the most tennis singles grand slam wins?
Most people will tell you it's djokovic with 24.
However margaret court also had 24.
Did that not count because its a different competition?
You can do similar with golf etc

Quote from: kruddler – on November 01, 2025, 11:07:23 pm

Who has the most tennis singles grand slam wins?
Most people will tell you it's djokovic with 24.
However margaret court also had 24.
Did that not count because its a different competition?
You can do similar with golf etc

what's the world record for the 100 metres dash?

Do women's have a seperate world record?

You can say what you have said, and its correct, but im sure that we wouldnt cross code those streaks if other sports yielded a team with this record.

It actually loses credibility to attempt to do so.