Skip to main content
Topic: Name your team for Opening Round (Read 3927 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #15
I'll play. (Nice format, David).

B:     Newman   Weitering   Dean

HB:  Florent   Haynes   Cowan

C:    F. Young   Lord   Acres

HF:  Motlop  Harry   Evans

FF:   Hayward   Kemp   Williams

R:   Pitto   Crippa   J Smith

I:   Walsh   Saad   Cerra   Cottrell   Moir

E:  Wilson, Ainsworth, O'Keefe (sorry David, snuck in emergencies  ;D )
Only our ruthless best, from Board to bootstudders will get us no. 17

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #16
My approach is to have at least three players capable of playing on the wing among my seven or eight midfielders.  They should have plenty of stamina, the ability to nullify their opponent, be able to break the lines, and hit targets inside 50.

On paper at least, we have plenty of candidates; Acres, the Camporeales, Chesser, Cottrell, O Hollands, and Smith, and Cerra, Haynes, Lord and Walsh all played on the wing last season as did Docherty and Binns.

Acres was hampered by a bulging disc last season and was way below his best.  He looks to be moving freely again and, if he can regain his previous form, should be a monty on one wing. 

The Camporeales have potential and I expect both to play in 2026.  They will need things to go their way if they get the nod over those ahead of them in the pecking order.

Chesser comes into our squad in place of Docherty/Binns and his injury history means that he’s a bit of an unknown quantity.  He was a very highly regarded junior and was taken as a first round draft pick despite suffering meniscus damage in his draft year.  His first pre-season crashed when he smashed his ankle and ongoing ankle issues, and another knee injury, restricted him to just 32 games in his first three seasons.  He had ankle surgery in the 2025 pre-season and missed the first half of the season before earning a place in the Eagles’ side for the last four games.  His form in those games was the best of his career and finally revealed his ability.  The point of difference with our other candidates for a role on the wing is his genuine foot speed.  However, that’s not going to get him a game by itself, and I’d have him just ahead of the Camporeales in the pecking order, unless he can show the form that demolished Ed Langdon in round 21.

Matty Cottrell really cemented his place in the team as a link up high half forward but there’s a lot more competition for spots in the forward line now and I suspect that his best chance of a senior recall will be on the wing.  Of course, there’s plenty of competition for winger roles too and Matty has to overcome his stress fracture issues.

The arrival of Ollie Florent probably means that Ollie Hollands won’t be required in defence this season and wing is probably his best position.  Ollie rarely loses a one on one contest and he has an ability to create contests when the opposition seems likely to break away.  Ollie’s not quick though and his kicking can lack penetration and accuracy.

I’m not sure where Jagga Smith will play in 2026, but he could line up on the wing.  He is fast, elusive, reads the play well, makes good decisions and is a good user of the ball.  I don’t know about his defensive work but, if he’s the one with the pill, he doesn’t need to defend.

My pecking order for a spot on the wing in Opening Round is Acres (subject to fitness), O Hollands, Smith, Cottrell (subject to fitness), Chesser, L Camporeale and B Camporeale.  Walsh, Cerra and Lord could be in the mix too, if required.

Then there’s Nick Haynes.  The experiment of playing him on the wing in the last two rounds was a success and he could provide us with a different look and more marking power in our midfield.  McGovern has been training with the defenders and I don’t think we’d necessarily go with both him and Haynes in defence.  If Haynes is training with the midfielders, I won’t be surprised if he’s on the wing in Opening Round.
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #17
Newman, Weitering McGovern
Saad Haynes Florent
Cottrell Cripps Chesser
Ainsworth McKay Motlop
Hayward Kemp Williams

Reidy Hewett Walsh

Cerra, Smith, Cowan, Carroll

Side looks well balanced however it’s clear that unless one of McGovern, Haynes, Dean or Kemp stands up as a key defender we’ll be exposed.  Other concerns are our ability to defend clever/strong small forwards & the durability of Cottrell & Chesser who could provide much needed pace.

All of Cripps, Weitering, Smith, Hewett, Walsh, Kemp, McKay, Cerra, Hayward, Saad and possibly McGovern have the ability to make the AA squad so let’s hope we see at least half of them get there.

Unlucky not to make the side  - Okeefe (could swap with Kemp), Dean (could swap with Haynes or McGovern), Lord, Pittonet, Acres, Boyd, Hollands, Moir & Evans

Hey dorotich you're short one on the interchange

Thanks I wasn’t across that - I’d add Okeefe in that case

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #18
When there is a line ball between a couple of players, high class disposal efficiency will win the position. For too long we've had great foot soldiers who have poor disposal.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #19
When there is a line ball between a couple of players, high class disposal efficiency will win the position. For too long we've had great foot soldiers who have poor disposal.

You’d certainly like to think that was the case 🤔
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

 

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #20
Newy        Weeters     Cowan
Saad         Haynes      Dean
Cotters     Crippa      Acres
Ainsworth   Gov        Zac
Hayward      H          Mots
Pitto          Hewitt     Walsh
int : Cerra   OHollands  Jagga  Florent
emerg:  Kemp   Moir  O'Keeffe  Lord

inj :  OFarrel

depth :  Evans, Caroll, Chesser, Fogarty, Campox2,  Young(F&L), EHollands(?), Charleston, Wilson, Boyd, Reidy, Ison,

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #21
Newy        Weeters     Cowan
Saad         Haynes      Dean
Cotters     Crippa      Acres
Ainsworth   Gov        Zac
Hayward      H          Mots
Pitto          Hewitt     Walsh
int : Cerra   OHollands  Jagga  Florent
emerg:  Kemp   Moir  O'Keeffe  Lord

inj :  OFarrel

depth :  Evans, Caroll, Chesser, Fogarty, Campox2,  Young(F&L), EHollands(?), Charleston, Wilson, Boyd, Reidy, Ison,


Handy bench

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #22
Zero Hangar have done one.....
https://www.zerohanger.com/selecting-every-afl-teams-best-23-for-2026-carlton-blues-171945/
FB: Harry Dean, Jacob Weitering, Nic Newman
HB: Adam Saad, Nick Haynes, Oliver Hollands
C: Jagga Smith, George Hewett, Adam Cerra
HF: Ben Ainsworth, Harry McKay, Will Hayward
FF: Jesse Motlop, Brodie Kemp, Zac Williams
FO: Marc Pittonet, Patrick Cripps, Sam Walsh
I/C: Lachlan Cowan, Oliver Florent, Campbell Chesser, Francis Evans, Hudson O'Keeffe

Stiff to miss: Liam Reidy, Mitch McGovern, Blake Acres, Lachie Fogarty, Matthew Cottrell, Cooper Lord, Ashton Moir

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #23
Not a bad side, but I think Moir and Lord will both be in the opening round side
I'm backing Lord to be the one to watch this year.

From the side above...Chesser might have to wait
Moir ahead of Motlop.

The thing is we'd be fairly lucky (unusually so for us) for all of the 'Hangar' side to be available Round 1, so 'squeezing' players in might not be an issue.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #24
I think Lewis Young will be playing.  He had a good year last season, but he had a bad season the year  before. I always think we need a tall defender around 200cm. If Harry O'Farrell was available he would be an automatic selection for me and Young is the only player on our list that meets this requirement.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #25
It wouldn't surprise to see L Young playing first up.
They may use Dean off the bench in the early stages, but I think he'll be somewhere in the Round 1 side.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #26
It wouldn't surprise to see L Young playing first up.
They may use Dean off the bench in the early stages, but I think he'll be somewhere in the Round 1 side.

Weitering is a no brainer.
Haynes is the next best.
How do you fit both young and dean in the backline as well....and everyone needs to stop with the haynes on the wing nonsense, its not a legitimate position change.
....and there is always a potential for mcgovern as well.

To me, young just cant get in ahead of dean for any length lf time.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #27
The one pick I am seeing that surprises me from most posts is Saad. While I have loved his endeavour and his output I was thinking 2025 may have been his final year - seemed he didn't finish that strongly and may have gone out on a 'high'. Glad he stayed on for 2026 but I question him being an auto pick each week. Seems most posts here put him in the starting team for round 1 (or is that zero). I'm putting Newman and Cowan ahead of him at this stage. Then there is O Hollands and Florent.
Fingers crossed for a big 2026 for Saad - the team is def stronger when he is moving the ball quickly out of defence.

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #28
It wouldn't surprise to see L Young playing first up.
They may use Dean off the bench in the early stages, but I think he'll be somewhere in the Round 1 side.

Weitering is a no brainer.
Haynes is the next best.
How do you fit both young and dean in the backline as well....and everyone needs to stop with the haynes on the wing nonsense, its not a legitimate position change.
....and there is always a potential for mcgovern as well.

To me, young just cant get in ahead of dean for any length lf time.

It's a shame we don't have tall depth in the backline. :D

Re: Name your team for Opening Round

Reply #29
The one pick I am seeing that surprises me from most posts is Saad. While I have loved his endeavour and his output I was thinking 2025 may have been his final year - seemed he didn't finish that strongly and may have gone out on a 'high'. Glad he stayed on for 2026 but I question him being an auto pick each week. Seems most posts here put him in the starting team for round 1 (or is that zero). I'm putting Newman and Cowan ahead of him at this stage. Then there is O Hollands and Florent.
Fingers crossed for a big 2026 for Saad - the team is def stronger when he is moving the ball quickly out of defence.

I think it's a bit of a wait and see with Saad
Was his contribution last year affected by injury, or was it more a case of age catching up with him.
At or near his best he's definitely worth a spot.