Carlton Supporters Club

Play Williams on him and run a sweep Gulden under or over 40 possessions

Surely Binns deserves a run, given his performances over a run of VFL games.

Other clubs will be having a hard look at him if we continue to ignore.

Ab

Could you run someone like Marchbank or Kemp as a defensive forward hard tagging Blakey?

I think stop Blakey's run and you smash Sydney's ball movement, he's the trigger for a huge percentage of the Swans attacking plays.

No but our injury list even without the usual suspects is still unacceptable as the bulk of them as soft tissue injuries.

Plus blokes breaking down the week they return like Cerra last week is fully on him.

And send Russell with them.

Put them all on long term injury lists and replace them with mid season draft picks. At least we will know they are going to be 35-40 players on the list and give VFL abit of depth.

My Side is:
FB Newman Weitering Cincotta
HB Boyd McGovern Kemp
C O Hollands Cripps Acres
HF E Hollands McKay Martin Kennedy
FF Durdin Curnow Owies
R De Koning Walsh Hewett
Int Cowan Carroll Williams Binns
Sub Fantasia
Out Pittonet Cottrell Cerra Martin
In Carroll Williams Binns Fantasia
Pitto is a test but won't play
Williams is a test and will play

I have been saying this forever and a day - don't need superstars just dependable players that can play a role we already have dependable and reliable superstars. Continuing with these players is untenable.

Martin broken down again! Re injured his calf.

Time to put a line thru this bloke or how long did we re sign our SC guru for again?

Year in year out constantly have the comps
worst injury lists - wont win a flag if this continues

Assuming his numbers are right, he does have a point. He is a Swans great, a member of their Team Of The Century, and a commentator of some repute. You hope he would know.

Appreciate he might have to play but I wouldn't want him down back and maybe a sub role would suit..m