Re: Post Game Pondering: AFL 2020 Rd 9: Carlton vs Hawthorn
Reply #85 –
We're the club that has two speeds plus a once a year meeting with a 'Dishlishers' who we easily account for.
Speed one is a narrow loss or win. Speed two is being easily accounted for and as I mentioned, speed 3 is reserved for one game a year when we win comfortably... a la Dishlickers at the present moment. We could just as easily be sitting 2nd bottom with one win at present.
What exactly is our culture; our brand? Seems pretty mysterious to me. Something like, 'when things are going our way we finesse and look fantastic and kick goals... until our opponents turn up, apply pressure, then we go to water.' Seems when we're ferocious, we do well but that ferocity is very conditional and fluctuates and is entirely dependent upon what the opposition does... it's apparently a very moody ferocity.
Our conservatism at the selection table is telling and needs changing. I understand we want to send a message to blokes that we trust them and that they belong... but there should be another message, 'perform poorly and you're out, plenty of blokes/newbies who deserve a gig to take your place'.
When we were desperate against the Dawks how 'individual' did we play... holy mackerel, so many trying to be the 'saviour'... symptom of poor discipline and no culture/brand.
As for individuals... what the hec is up with Crippa? Doc troubled by attention and lack of freedom... there go the skippers. Cuningham does his usual invisible man stunt for extended periods and then gives us hope with a sublime goal, only to shrink away again. Murphy makes demoralising errors... and when a leader (?) does that the negative ripple effect is influential. What you see with SPS is what happens when a creative bloke is given a negative role.
I wonder if the coaching ranks need a Ross Lyon... someone who understands high levels of discipline and has a bit of shizen on his liver to pass on to others. Our niceness is a serious issue, and not in a good way.
We need to make some very hard decisions at year's end re personnel and assistant coaches.
Very good summation, excellent in fact however a couple things if I may:
- There is absolutely nothing "fericious" about the way we play, ever, zero, zilch. That the BIGGEST problem we have. Richmond are ferocious all day every day, Hawks were once upon a time, doggies are every now and then, us? Nope.
- SPS is cooked. He isn't a defender, he isn't a mid, he isn't a fwd, he isnt a negating player, he is a liablity. He alone yesterday caused 3 goals by either fumbling, lack of awareness, got tackled and didnt dispose. Cant or doesnt kick more than 15-20m. If we lucky, a WA club will trade with us for him. Ive been a big critic from very early, I was told to be patient, he's creative, rubbish. He IS NOT the type player we need.
- Cunningham, see SPS.