Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments  (Read 385132 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #795 –
Australia is a relative minnow on the world stage, and performative tough guy antics from our politicians, wherever on the spectrum they sit, are frankly irrelevant.

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #796 –
Australia is a relative minnow on the world stage, and performative tough guy antics from our politicians, wherever on the spectrum they sit, are frankly irrelevant.
@Paulp It's not your fault you believe a message you have be told by local politicians and bureaucrats for decades.

Our resources and technologies and getting access to them pack a much bigger punch than our economy, literally and figuratively speaking our lack of economic growth is primarily due to the historical sell the farm attitude.

I've worked in R&D for over two decades, we've developed products worth billions on the global market, and not a single one has made it commercially within our own borders. By analogy I even suffered the insult a couple of weeks back. A local client advised me he had no intention of buying "Holden" when he could buy "Mercedes", except in his case the Mercedes he talks of is a product based on technology and resources developed here, licensed to Germany, and made in Germany using exported Australian resources using replicated Australian technology. The attitude is endemic. In the meantime, we have Japan, Italy, Canada, Saudi Arabia, the USA, and a host of other international players beating a path to our door, we can't win a local client but the local clients will buy the technology back via a foreign supplier.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #797 –
@Paulp It's not your fault you believe a message you have be told by local politicians and bureaucrats for decades.

Our resources and technologies and getting access to them pack a much bigger punch than our economy, literally and figuratively speaking our lack of economic growth is primarily due to the historical sell the farm attitude.

I've worked in R&D for over two decades, we've developed products worth billions on the global market, and not a single one has made it commercially within our own borders. By analogy I even suffered the insult a couple of weeks back. A local client advised me he had no intention of buying "Holden" when he could buy "Mercedes", except in his case the Mercedes he talks of is a product based on technology and resources developed here, licensed to Germany, and made in Germany using exported Australian resources using replicated Australian technology. The attitude is endemic. In the meantime, we have Japan, Italy, Canada, Saudi Arabia, the USA, and a host of other international players beating a path to our door, we can't win a local client but the local clients will buy the technology back via a foreign supplier.

None of which has anything to do with the point I'm making.

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #798 –

None of which has anything to do with the point I'm making.
Your point has a foundation in only a half truth, the irony for me is that my associates in the UK or Canada see things very differently and they often berate their own authorities for not following our lead. In fairness this is contrast by the opposite view from Asian countries who largely agree with your view that we are an irrelevant minnow. Of course there is always some regional or cultural bias.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #799 –
Your point has a foundation in only a half truth, the irony for me is that my associates in the UK or Canada see things very differently and they often berate their own authorities for not following our lead. In fairness this is contrast by the opposite view from Asian countries who largely agree with your view that we are an irrelevant minnow. Of course there is always some regional or cultural bias.

Australia has never been a main player on the world stage, not militarily, not politically, not economically, and not socially.

Foreign states are not intimidated by individual politicians and their nonsense. What keeps them up at night is the military, strategic, political and economic might of the countries those politicians represent.

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #800 –
Your point has a foundation in only a half truth, the irony for me is that my associates in the UK or Canada see things very differently and they often berate their own authorities for not following our lead. In fairness this is contrast by the opposite view from Asian countries who largely agree with your view that we are an irrelevant minnow. Of course there is always some regional or cultural bias.

Australia has never been a main player on the world stage, not militarily, not politically, not economically, and not socially.

Foreign states are not intimidated by individual politicians and their nonsense. What keeps them up at night is the military, strategic, political and economic might of the countries those politicians represent.


Bang on Paul

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #801 –
Australia has never been a main player on the world stage, not militarily, not politically, not economically, and not socially.

Foreign states are not intimidated by individual politicians and their nonsense. What keeps them up at night is the military, strategic, political and economic might of the countries those politicians represent.
Is Israel a big player, what about Taiwan, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Ireland, Singapore, Italy, Indonesia, etc., etc., where do they sit on the influence table relative to Australia?

It will help me understand your position on Australia if you clarify your position on a few other countries.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #802 –
Is Israel a big player, what about Taiwan, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Ireland, Singapore, Italy, Indonesia, etc., etc., where do they sit on the influence table relative to Australia?

It will help me understand your position on Australia if you clarify your position on a few other countries.

Paulie's Phantom Draft of National Global Influence ? I won't be doing that. It feels like a huge waste of time. My point is pretty simple, and has nothing to do with minerals or a few whizzo technical innovations.

If you believe that the world shakes when our politicians act tough, or that we can have a meaningful impact on global events, then I don't know what to tell you. It's pretty self evident to me.


Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #804 –
I have given up waiting for Tony Abbott to “shirtfront” Putin but it was refreshing to hear Albo tell Putin to, “End your war, end it now!”

Yeah Albo is such a hero - makes me so proud he is our 'leader' ::)

Putin would have been shaking in his boots having Albo demanding he end to the war :))

All jokes aside just another one of Albo's meaningless spin.... I doubt Putin even knows who the dopey fool is.
 
 


You've missed the point entirely. 

It's not about Albo the person, it's about Albo the Australian PM.

Australia is not a middle power, it is a significant power and with other similar world powers – such as Canada and EU states – we can wield considerable influence.  Obviously, Australia calling for Putin to end the war will not stop it, but it may galvanise other nations to take a stand against Russian aggression,
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #805 –


Yeah Albo is such a hero - makes me so proud he is our 'leader' ::)

Putin would have been shaking in his boots having Albo demanding he end to the war :))

All jokes aside just another one of Albo's meaningless spin.... I doubt Putin even knows who the dopey fool is.
 
 


You've missed the point entirely. 

It's not about Albo the person, it's about Albo the Australian PM.

Australia is not a middle power, it is a significant power and with other similar world powers – such as Canada and EU states – we can wield considerable influence.  Obviously, Australia calling for Putin to end the war will not stop it, but it may galvanise other nations to take a stand against Russian aggression,

I tend to agree.
Abbott was/is cringeworthy.
I havent seen the context of Albos comment but theres no negatives amongst our peers or underlings when we take a principled stand.
Let’s go BIG !

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #806 –
Australia has never been a main player on the world stage, not militarily, not politically, not economically, and not socially.

Foreign states are not intimidated by individual politicians and their nonsense. What keeps them up at night is the military, strategic, political and economic might of the countries those politicians represent.
Is Israel a big player, what about Taiwan, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Ireland, Singapore, Italy, Indonesia, etc., etc., where do they sit on the influence table relative to Australia?

It will help me understand your position on Australia if you clarify your position on a few other countries.
Much higher than Australia.

"everything you know is wrong"

Paul Hewson

 

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #807 –
There's a fair bit of the old cultural cringe going on ...

Australia is in the G20.
Australia has the 15th largest economy in the world.
Australia is the 12th largest contributor to the UN regular and peacekeeping budgets.
Australia is ranked 17th out of 145 countries globally in the 2026 Global Firepower Military Strength Index (15th by Credit Suisse).
Australia is ranked the 5th or 6th military power in Asia.
Australia is ranked 1st in Economic Demonstrated Resources for nine commodities—gold, ilmenite, iron ore, lead, rutile, uranium, vanadium, zinc, and zircon—and is ranked first in production for iron ore, lithium, and rutile.
Australia ranks 11th on the Economist Intelligence Unit Democracy Index, but only 26th on egalitarianism.
Australia's legal system is ranked 1st.
Australia is ranked 1st for adopting and adapting frontier technologies.
Australia is ranked 4th for talent attractiveness.
Australia is the 5th-most attractive destination for investment in renewable energy.
Australia is the 2nd largest exporter of energy and resources.
Australia is the 6th largest producer of solar energy.
The Australian dollar is the 6th-most traded currency worldwide.
"Negative waves are not helpful. Try saying something righteous and hopeful instead." Oddball

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #808 –


Yeah Albo is such a hero - makes me so proud he is our 'leader' ::)

Putin would have been shaking in his boots having Albo demanding he end to the war :))

All jokes aside just another one of Albo's meaningless spin.... I doubt Putin even knows who the dopey fool is.
 
 


You've missed the point entirely. 

It's not about Albo the person, it's about Albo the Australian PM.

Australia is not a middle power, it is a significant power and with other similar world powers – such as Canada and EU states – we can wield considerable influence.  Obviously, Australia calling for Putin to end the war will not stop it, but it may galvanise other nations to take a stand against Russian aggression,

Russia listens to very few if any and there is not one country that would listen to Albos pissing in the wind comments and use it to inspiration to unite with Australia. What a crook of sh1te. We would be at the bottom of the list to influence anyone let along a super power especially with a bozo like Albo on the world stage! 

As a matter of fact not only so we have no influence we are a sitting duck defense wise if certain zones near us ever break out to full out war. 

You can't be 'a significant power' (as you call us) without an ability to defend itself (to a point).    

If it wasnt for our geographical advantage highly likely we would have been taken over a long time ago
 

Re: Shawny’s concerns about Victorian and Australian Governments

Reply #809 –
Russia listens to very few if any and there is not one country that would listen to Albos pissing in the wind comments and use it to inspiration to unite with Australia.
Nuclear powers don't feel military threats, but Russia is dead broke, it's per capita domestic product is lower than the Maldives. Economically, they are 3rd world.

Weapons mean nothing, they use the bomb they starve to death as a nation, even if nobody retaliates they won't deal with them, China knows the very same, neither can survive on their own.

Putin waves the nuke to keep countries feeding his people, economic minnows fold, those who fold keep the war machine going.
"Extremists on either side will always meet in the Middle!"