Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Recent Posts
3
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by LP -

Why would you assume I was ignorant of the changing climate & local habitats ?
My comment was a generalisation about the assumptions the public make, people are very very bad at the relative understanding of many things, geologic or universe time frames, planetary or stellar mass, the speed of light, distances or dimensions beyond a few hundred metres or below a millimetre.

When discussing migration patterns, the discussion often proceeds like it's a journey, but it is normally discussing a journey that would typically take many generations. Same applies to talk about migration under climate change.

The other day I listened to an official BBC podcast about the Hubble space telescope that reported 50µm was 1/50th the width of a human hair, it was reporting this while describing the errors "engineers" made in calculating critical units! The correct figure would be 5µm is about 1/50th of the width of an average human hair.
4
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by northernblue -
All those things and also something much simpler… the carrying capacity of the land.
It's quite wrong to form an opinion based in current modern assumptions, the very article @PaulP links is an example of that, desserts now where forests used to be, and a total population that was just a fragment of what it has been for most of modern history.

Why would you assume I was ignorant of the changing climate & local habitats ?
5
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by DJC -
Why did the 'islanders' travel by boat to explore back in the day? Curiosity.
Why is it different on land?

Polynesian colonisation of the Pacific is a fascinating piece of human history and achievement.

It used to be thought that intrepid Polynesian explorers set out on suicide missions to find new lands or perish.  It's now apparent that they had the knowledge and means to return home while they still could.  Archaeological evidence reveals the Polynesians visited Australia and established short-lived colonies on Norfolk and Pitcairn Islands before the first European navigators.

It's a fictional account of course, but James A Michener's Hawaii presents a well-researched and historically and archaeologically sound account of the colonisation of Hawaii by Polynesians from the Marquesas who crossed 4,000km of open ocean.

The famous cultural anthropologist, Margaret Mead, documented extreme responses to embarassment among Samoans; farting during a meeting could result in suicide (by sitting on a palm spike!) or a voyage of discovery.  How many islands were discovered as a result of a fart?
8
Ladies Lounge / Re: AFLW 2026 Semi Final Carlton vs Hawthorn at Ikon
Last post by Gointocarlton -
ok so I watched again and must say i was yelling at the end. much better skills then last week and there is no denying the girls grit and want to compete.

Will be tuning in again next.

 
Good on you for giving it another go.

A much better game than last week, and some great moments!

Go Blues!
There is no question the skill level and watchability of the AFLW has go through the roof in recent years. I feel like Carlton especially has improved more than most teams. With a bit of luck, the girls can bring home some silverware this year which the boys will add to next year.
9
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by DJC -
Putting aside my evidence-based archaeological method, I'd like to think that it was curiosity and a sense of adventure, or perhaps even a dash of wanderlust, that motivated those ancient folk to head off into the unknown.
The old sins, greed, gluttony, desire all wrapped in hubris, the tale had to have deep social origins somewhere!

The apples are sweeter over the hill, and there is no more basic craving than to want something somebody else has already got!

There are incredibly strong motivations for staying put, as we know from families that have lived in the same village for generations.

In a hunter-gatherer society with a seasonal round of dwelling places rather than permanent homes, intimate knowledge of the home environment; resource locations, where the predators hang out, places to shelter, refuges when times are tough; would have been a powerful reason to stay put.  Then there's friendly neighbours to trade with and inter-marry, and not so friendly neighbours that are to be avoided, as well as places associated with creation stories, totemic sites, etc

Leaving home would generally require compelling reasons and I think that curiosity could be one such reason for some folk.
10
Blah-Blah Bar / Re: General Discussions
Last post by Thryleon -
Theres evidence of humans living 200 000 years ago in parts of Europe. 

Odds are they moved as the temperatures shifted.

Hot and cold up and down hills, near food, away from earthquakes and weird weather patterns. 

Realistically there's a lot of stuff we are still working out and the out of Africa theory is just one theory.